What to Hire as a Small Business Owner in Australia: Qualifications or Experience?
Disclaimer: This blog post is intended for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, or medical advice. Please consult with a qualified professional for advice tailored to your specific situation.
Running a small business in Australia is a challenging yet rewarding endeavor. Whether you operate a café in Melbourne, a boutique in Brisbane, or a tech start-up in Sydney, one key decision you will face as your business grows is hiring the right people. But when it comes to choosing between qualifications and experience, how do you make the right call?
This debate is not new, but it remains a crucial topic for small business owners who often have limited resources to allocate to hiring. The wrong hire can be costly—not just in terms of money but also productivity and morale.
This blog post explores the pros and cons of prioritizing qualifications versus experience in hiring for your Australian small business, helping you make informed decisions.
Understanding the Hiring Dilemma
As a small business owner, you may not have the luxury of a dedicated human resources team. Hiring decisions often rest solely on you, which means it’s essential to know exactly what your business needs and how to evaluate candidates effectively.
When looking at a potential employee’s qualifications, you’re focusing on their formal education, certifications, and training. This might include university degrees, TAFE certifications, or industry-specific courses. On the other hand, experience refers to the practical knowledge and skills they’ve gained by working in the field.
Both qualifications and experience have their advantages, but which is more important for a small business in Australia? Let’s explore each side.
The Case for Hiring Based on Qualifications
1. Demonstrates Foundational Knowledge
One of the biggest advantages of hiring a qualified candidate is that their education often provides a solid foundation of theoretical knowledge.
For example:
A marketing graduate will likely understand concepts like digital advertising, SEO, and analytics.
A qualified accountant will have a grasp of Australian tax laws and financial best practices.
This foundational knowledge can be crucial in certain fields where technical expertise is non-negotiable.
For example, if your business requires legal or financial expertise, hiring someone with the right qualifications ensures compliance with Australian laws and regulations.
2. Industry-Specific Certifications
In Australia, certain industries require certifications by law.
For example:
A construction worker must hold a White Card to work on-site.
A childcare worker must have a Certificate III in Early Childhood Education and Care.
A professional accountant may need CPA Australia accreditation.
When qualifications are legally or ethically required, there’s no room for compromise. Even in industries where certifications aren’t mandatory, they can act as a benchmark of quality and professionalism.
3. Up-to-Date Knowledge
Educational institutions and training programs are often updated to reflect new trends and technologies in the industry.
For example, a data analyst with a recent qualification will likely be familiar with the latest software and methodologies, while someone with experience alone might still be relying on outdated tools.
4. Signals Dedication and Ambition
Earning qualifications takes time, effort, and financial investment. A candidate with relevant qualifications demonstrates a level of dedication and ambition that can be valuable for your business. They’ve shown they are willing to work hard to achieve their goals—an attitude that could benefit your team.
The Case for Hiring Based on Experience
1. Practical Knowledge of the Job
While qualifications provide theoretical knowledge, experience teaches practical, real-world skills.
For example:
A barista who has worked in multiple cafes will likely know how to handle a busy morning rush better than someone with a hospitality degree but no hands-on experience.
A marketing professional with years of experience running campaigns will have valuable insights into what works and what doesn’t, even if they lack formal training.
Practical knowledge is particularly important in small businesses, where employees often need to hit the ground running.
2. Problem-Solving Skills
Experienced workers have likely faced and resolved challenges in the workplace. They know how to adapt to unexpected situations, manage stress, and find creative solutions—qualities that are invaluable for any business.
For example, consider a retail manager who has dealt with everything from difficult customers to inventory shortages. Their ability to problem-solve in real time can be more valuable than someone who has studied retail management but hasn’t yet faced these challenges.
3. Industry Connections
Experienced candidates often bring a network of industry contacts with them, which can be beneficial for your business. Whether it’s suppliers, clients, or other professionals, these connections can help your business grow faster than someone with no prior experience.
4. Cost-Effectiveness
Hiring someone with experience may reduce the need for extensive training, saving time and money. This is especially important for small businesses with limited resources. While qualifications can teach the theory, experience often reduces the learning curve.
5. Proven Track Record
Experience allows you to evaluate a candidate’s past performance. You can look at their career history, ask for references, and even review measurable achievements, such as sales figures or completed projects. This provides a clearer picture of what they’re capable of compared to someone whose qualifications don’t yet translate into real-world success.
The Australian Context: Why It Matters
1. The Skills Shortage
Australia’s labor market is experiencing ongoing skills shortages in many industries, from healthcare to trades. According to the National Skills Commission, some of the most in-demand roles include electricians, software engineers, and aged care workers.
For small businesses, this means hiring decisions are often a balancing act between finding someone with the right qualifications and someone with the necessary experience.
2. The Role of TAFE and Vocational Education
Australia has a strong vocational education system, with many small businesses relying on TAFE graduates. These programs often blend qualifications with hands-on training, making TAFE graduates a good middle ground between theoretical knowledge and practical experience.
3. Regional and Rural Challenges
For small businesses in rural and regional areas, hiring can be even more challenging. Access to highly qualified candidates may be limited, making experience a more realistic priority. However, some government programs, such as apprenticeships and traineeships, can help bridge this gap.
4. Small Business Realities
Small businesses in Australia often operate on tight budgets and require employees who can wear multiple hats. This reality may make experience more valuable, as experienced workers are often more adaptable and independent.
Combining Qualifications and Experience: The Ideal Scenario
While the debate often positions qualifications and experience as separate entities, the truth is that the ideal hire has a combination of both.
For example:
A qualified accountant with five years of experience working with small businesses.
A hospitality worker with a Certificate III in Hospitality and several years of experience managing a restaurant.
Candidates who bring both qualifications and experience offer the best of both worlds: the theoretical knowledge to understand the "why" behind their actions and the practical skills to execute them effectively.
Practical Tips for Hiring in Australia
1. Define the Role Clearly
Start by identifying what your business needs. Is the role highly technical, requiring formal training? Or is it more hands-on, where experience will be more valuable?
For example:
A marketing strategist may require qualifications.
A sales executive may benefit more from experience.
2. Use Targeted Job Descriptions
When advertising the role, be clear about whether you prioritize qualifications, experience, or both.
For instance:
“Bachelor’s degree in Marketing or 2+ years of relevant experience preferred.”
“Must have a Certificate IV in Building and Construction and at least 3 years of on-site experience.”
3. Ask the Right Questions
During interviews, dig deeper into their qualifications and experience. Sample questions include:
For qualifications: “How has your degree/certification prepared you for this role?”
For experience: “Can you describe a challenging situation in your previous job and how you handled it?”
4. Consider a Trial Period
Many small businesses in Australia use probationary periods, typically three to six months, to assess a new hire’s suitability. This allows you to evaluate how their qualifications or experience translate into real-world performance.
5. Upskill Your Employees
If you find a candidate with great experience but lacking some qualifications—or vice versa—consider investing in their development. Australia offers many government-subsidized training programs, such as apprenticeships, that can help you upskill your team.
6. Leverage Technology
Use tools like LinkedIn, Seek, and Australian job boards to find candidates. These platforms often allow you to filter applicants based on qualifications and experience, making your hiring process more efficient.
The Final Verdict: Qualifications vs. Experience
So, what should you prioritize as a small business owner in Australia? The answer largely depends on your business needs, industry, and the specific role you’re hiring for.
Here’s a quick summary:
Choose Qualifications When:
The role requires technical or specialized knowledge (e.g., accounting, legal, healthcare).
Compliance with Australian regulations is essential.
You’re looking for someone with up-to-date industry knowledge.
Choose Experience When:
Practical skills and problem-solving abilities are more important than theory.
The role requires someone to hit the ground running with minimal training.
You value proven results and a strong professional network.
In many cases, a balance of both qualifications and experience is ideal. However, as a small business owner, it’s important to remain flexible and focus on finding the right person for your unique needs.
Final Thoughts
Hiring the right team is one of the most important steps in growing your Australian small business. While the debate between qualifications and experience will likely continue, the key is to align your hiring decisions with your business goals and the specific demands of the role.
By carefully considering the pros and cons of each, you can build a team that not only meets your needs but also helps your business thrive in the competitive Australian market.
Remember, every hire is an investment. Take your time, ask the right questions.
There are many ways of working with professionals. Start small, but keep it regularly and don’t wait until something happens. Strategic planning and periodic reviews are a great start to implement those strategies.
Perfectly Organised NT can assist with a financial review and strategic business planning & management. Find out more!
Perfectly Organised NT - helping small business owners in Australia manage their business.